Co-Creating Mobility Hubs: Methods for Assessing Societal Demands


This research project is part of an interdisciplinary project of SBB, ETH Zurich and EPF Lausanne and investigates the possible transformation of railway stations into so-called mobility hubs. The future development of rail-based transport hubs into intermodal mobility hubs is intended to create hubs that meet the requirements of a high quality of stay and a wide range of services for customers not traveling by rail. Mobility hubs could improve the interface between different modes of transportation, such as private and public rail systems, especially in suburban and regional population centers. Understanding the current and anticipating the future societal needs of different user groups is critical to the success of change efforts.

Introduction

While the development of transportation hubs is a central measure for optimizing land use and thus densifying urban spaces, such projects can provoke (local) resistance and trigger (local) public debates. As a consequence, a lack of public acceptance can lead to slower implementation of such projects. Securing public acceptance and support for densification is therefore crucial for the transformation of transportation hubs, specifically in metropolitan regions. The two methods developed in this chapter help identify both user and resident needs and potential impacts early on. This project therefore focused on two key research questions and, concomitantly, two methods to be developed for assessing societal needs:

  1. Societal requirements survey: What are the demands of (potential) users of mobility hubs? The aim was to weigh and assess different functions of transport hubs and their design from the user's point of view.
  2. Analysis of spillover effects on society: What are potential spillover effects of mobility hubs on surrounding (urban) areas? The effects of rezoning and supply expansion on the surrounding areas of developing mobility hubs were investigated.
Co-creating mobility hubs, © Michael Wicki

The Project

The (urban) space in Switzerland as well as the fabric of society are shaped by no infrastructure as much as by railroad stations. The development of railroad stations into mobility hubs is thus about more than just the renewal of buildings, spatial structures and functions. Rather, such developments also encompass the surroundings of mobility hubs, especially public spaces and the social fabric. Mobility hubs are thus not only important for the development of rail-bound transport and intermodal mobility but also for the spatial development of regions, cities and areas.

Such transformations not only affect railway stations themselves but their surrounding urban areas and consequently its residents. A mobility hub is thus more than an assembly of technical infrastructure and is part of a larger socio-technical system. Against the backdrop of better understanding whether mobility hubs can help urban areas to both densify and decarbonise, this research task thus focuses on three main research questions

  • What are demands for mobility hubs by current users/user groups, especially from a societal perspective?
  • How can mobility hubs transform mobility behavior, specifically of individuals who predominantly rely on their car?
  • What are potential spillover effects of mobility hubs on their surrounding urban areas?

Beyond other things, this project conducted survey experiments around the three train stations Bern Wankdorf, Ostermundigen and Nyon in 2021. The research project aimed to determine the requirements of future trainstations. In the survey, questions about respondents' attitudes toward offerings at the respective station, their mobility behavior, and themselves were included. This project has been successfully completed and the final report is available upon request. Results on the survey research can be found further below.




Team Members

Researcher

Sophie Hauller
  • HIL H 28.3

ISTP
Stefano-Franscini-Platz 5
8093 Zürich
Switzerland

Co-Principal Investigator

Prof. Dr. David Kaufmann
Assistant Professor at the Department of Civil, Environmental and Geomatic Engineering
Deputy head of Inst Spatial and Landscape Development / Head of Network City and Landscape ARCH and BAUG
  • HIL H 29.3
  • +41 44 633 94 84

Raumentwicklung und Stadtpolitik
Stefano-Franscini-Platz 5
8093 Zürich
Switzerland

Prof. Dr.  David Kaufmann

Researcher

Elena Lutz
  • HIL H 29.2
  • +41 44 633 34 27

Raumentwicklung und Stadtpolitik
Stefano-Franscini-Platz 5
8093 Zürich
Switzerland

Elena Lutz

Researcher

Dr. Michael Wicki
Lecturer
  • HIL H 31.2
  • +41 44 633 49 74

Raumentwicklung und Stadtpolitik
Stefano-Franscini-Platz 5
8093 Zürich
Switzerland

Dr.  Michael Wicki
JavaScript has been disabled in your browser